Millions of homeowners across the United States enjoy the luxury of having a swimming pool right in their backyard. Whether it’s for exercise, family fun, or relaxation, pools are a cherished addition to any home. In regions like the Northeast when the sun isn’t always on its best behavior, taking a dip in the chilly water may not be so appealing. But if you’re looking to make your swimming season more comfortable and enjoyable, investing in a pool heater is the way to go. Read on to learn more about two of the most effective heating options – gas heaters and heat pumps – and which one to choose for your pool. 

Is a Gas Heater Right for Me?

Gas heaters for pools operate using either propane or natural gas. They are known for their effectiveness in quickly heating pool water, making them an attractive option for pool owners who desire immediate warmth. One of the significant advantages of gas heaters is their precise temperature control, allowing users to adjust the water temperature to their liking with ease. This control over temperature is particularly appealing for those who prefer their pool water at specific warmth levels for comfort or therapeutic purposes.

Another benefit of gas heaters is their reliability, especially in colder climates where maintaining a consistent pool temperature is essential. Unlike some other heating methods, gas heaters can swiftly raise the water temperature, ensuring that your pool remains comfortable even during cooler weather spells or evenings. Additionally, gas heaters are less affected by external factors such as air temperature or weather conditions, making them a dependable choice for maintaining ideal pool temperatures year-round.

However, it’s essential to consider the operational costs associated with gas heaters. The price of fuel, whether propane or natural gas, can fluctuate, impacting the overall expense of heating your pool. Additionally, gas heaters tend to consume more energy compared to other heating methods, which can result in higher utility bills. Despite these considerations, for pool owners seeking rapid heating and precise temperature control, gas heaters remain a popular and effective option.

Is a Heat Pump Right for Me?

Heat pumps offer an energy-efficient alternative to traditional gas heaters for pool heating. These devices operate by extracting heat from the surrounding air and transferring it to the pool water. While they may not heat the water as quickly as gas heaters, heat pumps provide a consistent and reliable heating solution throughout the year.

One of the primary advantages of heat pumps is their energy efficiency. By harnessing heat from the air, heat pumps require less electricity to heat the pool water compared to gas heaters. This energy-efficient operation can lead to significant cost savings on utility bills over time, making heat pumps an attractive option for environmentally conscious pool owners.

Additionally, heat pumps can efficiently heat pool water even when outdoor temperatures are cooler, ensuring that your pool remains comfortable for swimming year-round. Furthermore, heat pumps offer quiet operation and minimal maintenance requirements, providing added convenience for pool owners.

While heat pumps may have a higher initial investment compared to gas heaters, their long-term energy savings and environmentally friendly operation make them a compelling choice for many pool owners. Whether you prioritize energy efficiency, cost-effectiveness, or year-round comfort, heat pumps offer a reliable and sustainable solution for heating your pool.

Best East Rochester Pool Company

Ultimately, whether you opt for a gas heater or a heat pump, investing in a reliable heating system can significantly enhance your pool experience, allowing you to enjoy warm water regardless of the outside temperature. So, if you’re ready to extend your swimming season or make your pool more comfortable, contact the pool experts at Pettis Pools a call today or stop by one of our two pool stores in Greece and East Rochester to learn more about different heating options. Whether you’re building a new pool or are looking to upgrade your current pool with a new heater, we’re here to help.


Pettis Pools & Patios is a Greece pool builder proudly serving East Rochester, Wayne County, Ontario County and the surrounding areas. Family-owned and operated since 1962, Pettis Pools & Patios specializes in all pool and hot tub services, including new pool construction, hot tub sales & installation, and swim spa sales & installation. Pettis Pools & Patios also serves as a leading pool & hot tub service provider throughout the area, specializing in regular pool service, inground vinyl liner replacement, hot tub service, LOOP-LOC safety cover installations, and much more. Pettis Pools & Patios is proud to have two conveniently located pool supply stores in Greece and East Rochester, where pool owners can find all of their pool and hot tub care needs. 

For more East Rochester pool building information, like them on Facebook, follow them on Instagram or Pinterest, or subscribe to their YouTube channel. For pool design photos and inspiration, visit their online gallery to see what the expert pool design and construction team at Pettis Pools & Patios can do for you. Contact them today to get started designing your custom backyard oasis.